Culture Needs Its Critics, Not Just Its Cheerleaders
By Renee Howard
Loving the work means being willing to ask more of it — and making room for the conversations that follow.
Criticism has a bad reputation. In an era of stan culture and algorithmic amplification, the loudest voices are often the most enthusiastic ones. Nuance gets lost. Complexity gets flattened. Everything is either brilliant or trash.
But culture needs its critics. Not the kind who tear things down for sport, but the kind who take the work seriously enough to ask hard questions. What is this saying? What is it avoiding? Who does it serve? Who does it leave out?
Good criticism is an act of respect. It says: this work matters enough to engage with honestly. It creates the conditions for artists to grow and for audiences to develop taste beyond "I liked it" or "I didn't."
The alternative — a culture of pure celebration — sounds pleasant but produces stagnation. When everything is praised equally, nothing is understood deeply. We need people willing to say "this could be more" and mean it as a compliment.
Share this article